12-14
2010

Charity in a Can

When I was a kid my girl scout troop did a canned food drive for Christmas. This is something we are all familiar with- that holiday food drive at church or school.  I can still remember stacking dusty cans of cranberry sauce, salmon, and peas and thinking, “who would want to eat this stuff for Christmas dinner?”

Giving food to hungry people shouldn’t be about cleaning the back of the cupboard of the crap that you don’t want. I know what it is like to be hungry.  I grew up very, very poor- my mother, brother and I would split one small can of soup for dinner.  My mother would water it down and then break pieces of bread up into our bowls so it would fill us up.  If you are really, truly hungry you will eat anything to fill your belly up.  And I guess some people feel that if you are really, truly hungry you should be grateful for whatever you can get.

A good friend of mine is going through an extremely tough time this month.  She is having trouble putting food on the table.  Last week her inlaws brought over some food, for which I’m sure she was very grateful.   However after they left she opened the bag to find two ziploc bags of pasta, a five pound can of carrots and a box of powdered milk.  How is she supposed to make a meal from that?

Come on people- if all you are doing is reaching for the dustiest thing in the furthest reaches of your closet are you trying to help the person you are giving it to- or trying to make YOU feel better by convincing yourself that you have “helped” them?

I can speak from personal experience on this.  A few years ago we were having a very bad summer.  The huz had just switched jobs and we didn’t see a paycheck for over seven weeks because of an internal goof in payroll.  I was struggling to put food on the table for the six people in our household, including lunches my husband could take to work.  At times, I only had as little as twenty dollars a week for food, and I would carefully plan each week’s menu, calculating the cost of every single ingredient. Visits to the supermarket were mapped out and the grocery lists were memorized as if they were battle plans. It was very difficult but there was also a sense of pride in it- I was so proud that I could actually do it.  I could feed them good, healthy food on a teeny little budget.

Yummy (Cheap and Healthy) Lentil Stew For Dinner


One day a friend stopped by and dropped off bags of food that had been collected by a group of women I knew. I was genuinely touched by this.  They had obviously talked about my situation and decided to help.  Whilst the sentiment might have been genuine, it was somewhat of a let down to find the food parcel contained a hodgepodge of food items, such as out of date yams and other stuff, none of which could be combined to make a proper meal.  It made me feel bad- like because we were struggling we should be grateful for anything given to us.

I don’t ever want to make someone feel that way.  I think if you want to help someone you know who is struggling, you should give them everything it takes to make ONE ENTIRE meal (or two or three or four- depending on your budget).  Plan out a menu, go to the market and get them the things they need to make a dinner for their family.  Not odds and ends and bits from your cupboards.  It isn’t expensive- you can make a healthy dinner for under five dollars.  It just requires a little time and effort at the store to gather the things needed.

I felt so bad for my friend (of the carrots and milk fame) that on Saturday I planned out a week’s worth of dinners and took the littles to the grocery store.  We bought everything needed to make those meals and brought them to my friend.  It took a little money out of my budget and two and a half hours of my time to make someone else feel happy and cared for.  I think it was good for my kids too.  They kept asking for treats for themselves, and I had to explain that we were buying food for someone else.  They then changed their tune and started thinking of what the people we were buying food for might like in their basket.  I think that teaches my kids more than donating a can of cranberry sauce and a box of stuffing ever could.

Related Posts with Thumbnails


Click to add your comment



KitchenWitch says play nice.
I love talking with my readers!
Once your comment is posted it becomes the property of jonirae.com. Debate is fun, and if you play nice, we’ll get along… But if you are mean, rude, or otherwise disrespectful I may edit, reuse or delete the comment. My site, my rules.

Correct email addresses are required, but will never be published or shown in comments. Please use a valid address, because I may choose to respond to you via email.
By: Marita

Our local shopping centre (‘mall’ in USA speak) does a big charity food drive at Christmas time.

Last couple of years I have taken my oldest daughter to the supermarket and we go through the aisles and buy a whole days worth of food to make a special Christmas day treat. From cereal and UHT milk for breakfast through to dessert after dinner. She picks everything and I match her choices with a days worth of meals of my own.

As you say who wants a collection of out of date food that is all mixed up and can’t be used to make a meal.
Marita´s last post… The Great Big Lego Party – Pass the Lego Parcel

[Reply]

Joni Rae Reply:

That is AWESOME. I hope you inspire more people start doing that too!

(((HUG)))

<3

[Reply]



By: Rebecca

I have never thought of it like this but you are absolutely right. If someone is struggling how in the word can they make an actual meal out of a can of beans or bag of pasta? What good is that to them especially if the can is way past the expiration date?

[Reply]

Joni Rae Reply:

The expired stuff is the worst. It makes you feel like people don’t care enough to check the date on the can (Especially if it is someone you KNOW).

<3

[Reply]



By: Kristin Twitter:

Beautiful, thought-provoking post, thank you! I love the idea of going shopping with the kids for a full day’s worth of meals — wonderful!
Kristin´s last post… What I did today

[Reply]

Joni Rae Reply:

Thank you!

<3

[Reply]



By: Volante

Last summer a really good friend of mine was really struggling. So i sent her a care package. she had some money but was lacking some major pantry staples. I sent her pasta, sauce, tuna, veggies, canned chicken, cereal, granola bars (she has 6 kids), oatmeal and i’m sure several other non perishable items. of course she then proceeded to call me and *yell* at me when she received the package. as in her words “You don’t have the money to be doing this for me” i replied.. “I had a little extra and i wanted to help you stretch what you had for you and the kids, plus you’ve helped me a lot in the past”.

In the more recent years, because i’ve become way more food conscious, i look at labels, dates, etc. cleaned out my parent’s pantry of old outdated stuff (some really scary stuff) and i’ve even agreed to teach my brother’s girlfriend how to cook and buy better than overprocessed foods for her kids. (which can’t be helpful to the ones with medical conditions) I make sure to donate what i’d want to receive in a donated box if/when i do get them..which have been many times over the past several years with my own family (and more times than i can count growing up)

a great posting.

[Reply]

Joni Rae Reply:

OH I love that you did that for your friend! That is a fantastic gift, I’m sure she was very happy to get it.

<3 <3 <3

[Reply]



By: Rachael Twitter:

Do you have any tips for shopping for a food drive in which the food is distributed to a pantry? In other words, my donation will be broken up. Should I still buy for a meal or two or three or more, or are there types of foods that tend NOT to get donated and that I should favor, in order to balance out the other things that might be given? Everything has to be canned or boxed — no glass jars or fresh produce. Thank you!
Rachael´s last post… On My Mind- Belief

[Reply]

Joni Rae Reply:

Shopping for stuff is a great way to start- that gives the canned goods a longer shelf life at the pantry! You should call the pantry and ask them what they need. Most places have lists of the types of things that are needed and not donated often enough.

Great question!

<3

[Reply]



By: Melissa

YES! I can’t tell you how many times we’ve been given “care baskets” by our children’s school district and it is filled with stuffing, past date tuna helper with no tuna, cans of dusty yams and tiny bags of pasta. Nothing I can make anything out of, and the kids see it and refuse to even entertain the thought!

When I see someone asking for help on Freecycle, I go grocery shopping for them. I buy staples that they can use to make meals. When it is someone I personally know, I demand a shopping list (I say demand because usually I get “Oh no, its okay, whatever you think is fine”) because I know they have health issues/dietary restrictions and I want to make sure they have exactly what they need.

This is a great post.

[Reply]

Joni Rae Reply:

I love that you do that for people on freecycle. I never thought of doing that before!

<3

[Reply]



Joni- You bring up some important issues and I thank you for that. All too often, the food in the food pantry is expired.
Also, I wish people would donate healthy food (not things like Fruit Loops.)
Having food allergies/health issues makes getting food from a food pantry very difficult… it would be amazing if people could donate a gift card to a local grocery store. That way, families could choose the ingredients that they can actually eat. Of course, that would only work if you are donating it to someone in person but it makes a HUGE difference.
Thank you for getting the word out!
Barefoot Liz´s last post… Barefoot Books Discount Code

[Reply]

Joni Rae Reply:

Oh yes- having food allergies must make it REALLY hard to get food from a pantry :( Especially those places that put the box/bag of food together for you and don’t let you choose your own.

A gift card is also a good idea!

<3
Joni Rae´s last post… Charity in a Can

[Reply]



By: Amanda

Good point. Especially considering there are so many meals out there that require only 1-3 ingredients. One of my quick, cheap, lazy day meals involves mixing a tin of green lentils with a jar of pasta sauce and serving it with boiled pasta. It fills you up and tastes loves. I usually serve with simple boiled veg. So that’s what 3-4 ingredients that cost less that £4 probably. MUCH better than a tin of sweetcorn and box of powdered milk! ha!

A side sort of related note: I once volunteered at a soup kitchen with my Girl Scout troop. The person working there took a huge pot out of the fridge, heated it up, and instructed us to start dishing it out. We noticed a foul smell straight away but kept being ignored and told to keep serving it up. We must have served 30 people at least. Families with small children as well. We kept complaining but the person in charge started getting angry with us. My Dad then came to help out about half way through. He took one look and immediately took the huge pot outside to have a word with the person in charge. She got really angry. Said that “these people are grateful to get any food” and as the soup kitchen doesn’t get that much money she is going to continue serving it. The food was RANCID meat in a sort of tomato sauce/soup. The smell was making us girls who were serving it feel sick. My Dad sorted it out in the end and we had to serve cheese sandwiches instead. Better cheese sandwiches, milk, and fruit than rotten meat right? I just can’t believe that they would serve ROTTEN food to hungry people only a few days before Christmas. :( These were families who were living in their cars for pete’s sake. :( I hope nobody got sick. We were also given strict orders to not mention it to or around any of the soup kitchen’s patrons so they wouldn’t know they had been served rotten food. :(
Amanda´s last post… Countdown to Christmas Activities Part 1

[Reply]

Joni Rae Reply:

Oh that is really upsetting. I don’t understand how someone could think it is ok to serve rotten food to ANYONE. Never mind families and little kids that might have only that one meal that day.

This makes me very angry and breaks my heart.

People really do SUCK.
Joni Rae´s last post… Charity in a Can

[Reply]



By: AB

I love this post! You have a very good point.

Back in my early 20′s while going to school and working 2 jobs I was still very poor. It was my own mother that brought things that made since for meals and would last. I still thank her for that.

[Reply]



By: Fern

Basic foods we gave out at the shelter/food bank I worked at, for a family of 4 for one day:

Small box real oatmeal
One quart instant dry milk, suggested to use as half the liquid with oatmeal, half for later meal
2 15 oz cans fruit
One can tuna, depending on ages in household
One box mac and cheese (use more of milk making this)
Two cans soup, one cream to make tuna casserole with
Two 15 oz cans veggies
1/4 box crackers
One jar peanut butter
One jar jelly
One or two boxes Jello

We rarely had bread to give out, and never any fresh fruit, veggies, or meat. What we gave out was enough food for a day, tho’ very low in milk/milk products for children or pregnant women, and the peanut butter & jelly would have to be spread on crackers.

Now, this assortment is what I regularly donate to food banks myself.

[Reply]

Joni Rae Reply:

That’s good stuff! Stuff that can make decent meals :) I am so glad you do that. I wish more people did!

<3

[Reply]



Joni, this brought tears to my eyes. A few weeks ago, my daughter was visiting a friend’s house (single mother, two kids, minimal income) who is going through a tough time. They had her stay over for dinner, and she came home very upset. They ate beans and rice for dinner. When she went to grab something to drink, there were 3 items in the fridge.
As a parent, I can’t even imagine what it must be like not to be able to provide a fridge or pantry full of food for our children. I couldn’t stop thinking about it. I wanted to do something to help, but her friend’s mother was very embarrassed and didn’t want to accept anything from us. I thought up a plan. LOL I bought a $50 gift card from our local grocery store that has buy one get one free items (EVEN MEAT!) every week. I told her friend that my husband received it from his job as a Thanksgiving present but that I don’t like to shop at that store. As soon as the mom got home from work that day, they went and stocked up on food.
I found a local church that runs a food bank for the community but the mother won’t go. I am tempted to just drop off a box of food or put cash in their mail box but my daughter doesn’t want her friend to get angry with her. Its so frustrating!
I can’t imagine someone donating expired food items – are you freaking kidding me? How is that going to help?! Even if its a box of pasta noodles and a jar of sauce – it doesn’t have to be expensive to help someone make a decent dinner. Even a box of kraft macaroni and cheese would be better than expired food. :(
Jennifer Quillen´s last post… The holidays as a SAHM

[Reply]

Joni Rae Reply:

That’s a lovely thing you did. Pride is such a difficult beast to tackle. I have a hard time accepting help from others as well. But I’m sure she does appreciate the help. I would do it anyway, and just tell her that you would want her t do the same if times were tough for you. You are a really good person to care about another family like that!

<3 <3 <3

[Reply]



By: Tangie

I’m not trying to hijack the topic, but I just want to mention that many of the products that have dates on them have nothing to do with safety. Canned and jarred food can usually be safely consumed long after the date on the label….as long as the can or jar isn’t bulging, it’s likely to be fine. Same with dry goods. Some things may develop an “off” flavor if it’s SUPER old, but that doesn’t mean they’re unsafe to eat.

The care package contents that Fern listed above is the same sort of stuff we used to collect to prepare for Hurricane season when we lived in the Carolinas and Virginia.

[Reply]

Joni Rae Reply:

Thanks for that Tangie :) I didn’t know. I get nervous about canned/jarred food in general (which is why I haven’t started canning my own, even though I really want to- I’m scared I’ll do it wrong!)

<3 <3 <3

[Reply]



Excellent point! And thank you for making it. I’ve been that poor (and worse) and I totally understand. I rarely give food to charity (we do toys/clothes a lot) but this is a great reminder.
TheFeministBreeder´s last post… Kids Say the Gosh-Darndest Things

[Reply]

Joni Rae Reply:

Thank YOU for posting this on facebook! My stats have gone nuts!

<3 <3 <3

[Reply]



By: Maegan

In my home state there is a local grocery store that at holiday times or during “back to school” events does a brownbag…the bag has the items already in it…with a receipt stapled to it. So you could pick out a $5 bag or a $25 bag to purchase with your own groceries, then drop the bag off at the collection center at the exit. (The bags are places throughout the store on display.)

My mom could get pasta, old yams, and powdered milk into a meal! ;) As food bank survivors, it’s something we’ve had to do. We essentially lived on beans, rice, oatmeal, & grits for 3 years straight. Whenever I have donated I try to give things we would actually eat. I also do chicken & beef broth in addition to the items someone else listed above.
Maegan´s last post… Dashing all the way

[Reply]



By: Jody

Thank you for posting this.

I LOVE your suggestion of shopping for an entire meal when donating food. I had never thought of doing that but I will from now on for sure.
Jody´s last post… What’s For Dinner- Thursday Dec 9- Hamburger Macaroni

[Reply]

Joni Rae Reply:

Thank you! I’m not sure if it works for a food bank- but it is a wonderful thing to do for a friend that has bare cupboards. :)

<3

[Reply]



By: Amy

I really like this post. :-) I was allowing my kids to shop through my cabinets for donations to the food drive. I told them “Pick out food YOU would eat and donate it”. LOL. I remember as a kid, donating all the creamed corn. My mom said “That isn’t a sacrifice” and it has stuck with me ever since. I read another great post today and hope it’s okay to link it here:

http://blog.compassion.com/keeping-up-with-the-joneses-crackers-or-mud/

[Reply]

Joni Rae Reply:

That’s a great lesson for your kids :)

<3

[Reply]



By: Sarah Twitter:

A fantastic post, it really made me think!

I tweeted, put on FB, and stumbled it!
Sarah´s last post… Christmas Ponderings

[Reply]

Joni Rae Reply:

That;s because you are awesome. Love ya!

<3 <3 <3

[Reply]



By: Melodie Twitter:

My daughter’s pre-school is collecting food for the food bank and I took some over today: pasta, sauce, canned ravioli, canned soup, and… a can of cranberry sauce. Now I feel like a heel. I sure hope someone out there gets a use out of it but I don’t think I will be doing that again. Thanks for writing this and getting me to think.
Melodie´s last post… Emerging Family Traditions

[Reply]

Joni Rae Reply:

Oh Melodie! Don’t feel bad- I’m sure someone will be happy to get it :) I know my daughter Hannah LOVES the stuff and we eat it all year long! Anytime we have chicken or turkey… Out comes the can of cranberry sauce! You aren’t a heel- you donated useful foods, and more than just one old can.

<3

[Reply]



By: Caro

I’ve been raised in a humble household, but never experienced hunger at all… and thinking about people feeling it, makes me choke and floods my eyes. Whenever I can help someone, I try to give away only things I would buy for ourselves. You only have to put on those people’s shoes for a second, for God sake… empathy is such a rare gift…

[Reply]



By: nici

Wonderful post! I have a dear friend who is struggling to pay all the bills, and is a stellar cook who is passionate about feeding her family with the delicious foods she makes. I get around her pride by offering to bring all the ingredients for a double batch of something special that she would make her family if she could afford to, with the understanding that the 2nd half of the double batch is for my family. (She knows I hate to cook and am not very good at it!) For example, I come over for a visit with all ingredients for 6 quiches which she expertly makes; she serves two for dinner, saves one for breakfast and sends me home with 3 for the same. This way we do something for each other!
(Right now she is baking up a storm making Christmas cookies for both our families with ingredients I delivered. I consider myself and my family to be the lucky ones!)

[Reply]



Very good article! I know what it’s like to have to go once/twice a month to pick up a bit of food from a church or pantry. And when I was in my early teens, I helped and volunteered at our (then) local Allegheny Indian Center in collections, distribution, and some other secretarial/records stuff and we also received food from their pantry.

Thankfully, both then and recently, we have received meal-based bag/boxes. One church we have had to go to this year gives out a $25 gift card to Aldi’s (which is like a small grocery store that sells generic-brand foods) up to 6 times in a year for a family. Another offers a box of “essentials” that includes milk, eggs, and bread as well as letting people chose products from different groups of broken-down donations. (For example, a meat table would have chicken, beef, hot dogs, etc and would let someone pick, say, 2 meats from that table. Then a fruit such as grapes from the next table while getting a can of applesauce or fruit cocktail as a sort of automatic fruit).

Thank you for posting this article. I shared it on FB.
Keirston Howard´s last post… Where- oh where- has the time gone

[Reply]



By: Ida Mae Twitter:

great point! Really made me think. I shared it on fb and twitter!
~ida
http://www.treeswillbend.com
Ida Mae´s last post… Because

[Reply]



By: Colleen V

Thank you so much for this post–whenever we bring items to our church to be donated to local families and the local food pantry, I am constantly thinking, “if it were me, what would I want to eat.” Also, if it is items that are specifically meant for kids (ie: during the summer we collect items for kids who receive school lunch for free during the school year but cannot in the summer because they are not in school), I try to buy organic as that is what I would buy for my own child. I totally agree with your sentiments in this post and appreciate you taking the time to write about this.

[Reply]



By: Daniel Twitter:

It’s just amazing how sometimes you need help from your friends and you receive nothing. Currently, I am having a tough time and no matter how much I ask for help they turn the back on me.

When someone that I know needs help I really do anything and I mean ANYTHING for helping them. As you said before, at least If they need to eat I bring the whole meal and not just for feeling that I am doing the right thing but because I want to help.
Daniel´s last post… Split toe socks reviews

[Reply]



By: Alan Twitter:

I can relate to needing food (we get thirty bucks in food stamps a month, plus WIC, but it doesn’t stretch that far); we go to the monthly free meal a local church provides to help stretch our food budget.

But while I applaud a trip to the supermarket like the OP described, I don’t necessarily agree that there’s anything wrong with people donating odds and ends. I would gladly take such odds and ends that are just going to waste and taking up space in someone’s cupboard, and add them here and there as a supplement to the food we are already eating. I don’t see why food given has to add up to a full meal, as people usually are not dealing with completely bare cupboards (or if they are, they should be getting assistance beyond the kind of ad hoc efforts we are discussing here).
Alan´s last post… Voluntarily watching commercials–say what!

[Reply]



By: oceana

I’m late to reading this. but you are so right. I hope many people read this. We could all use lessons in how to REALLY help people :) @oceanamoon

[Reply]







CommentLuv badge